Understanding the Performance of tapply() and acast() when Grouping by Two Variables

===========================================================

The tapply() function from R’s base library is a powerful tool for aggregating data, while acast() from the reshape2 package is used for reshaping data. However, their performance can degrade significantly when grouping by two variables. In this article, we’ll explore why this happens and provide solutions using alternative methods.

Introduction to tapply() and acast()

tapply()

tapply() is a generic function in R’s base library that applies a function along the first dimension of an array-like object. It’s particularly useful for aggregating data when grouping by one or more variables. The general syntax for tapply() is:

tapply(x, indices, FUN = NULL)

x is the input data.
indices is a vector of values that defines the groups.
FUN is the function to be applied to each group. If omitted, the sum is used.

acast()

acast() from the reshape2 package is used for reshaping data. It transforms a long format into a wide format by pivoting on a specified column. The general syntax for acast() is:

acast(data, idvar, var1, var2, FUN = sum)

data is the input data.
idvar is the variable that defines the unique identifier for each group.
var1 and var2 are the variables to be pivoted on.

The Problem with tapply() and acast()

The problem lies in how these functions handle grouping by two variables. When we use tapply() or acast() to group data, they create intermediate objects that can consume significant memory and slow down performance.

Memory Consumption

The memory consumption issue arises because tapply() creates a temporary array to store the aggregated values, while acast() uses an additional layer of memory to store the reshaped data. These extra layers can lead to high memory usage, especially when dealing with large datasets.

# Example: Memory consumption using tapply()
mstart()
xx &lt;- tapply(bb$hour, list(bb$fi, bb$gi), sum, default = 0)
mstop()
# max memory used: 1135.9Mb.

Slow Performance

The performance degradation occurs because both tapply() and acast() involve extensive computation when grouping by two variables. The number of intermediate operations increases exponentially with the number of groups, leading to slower execution times.

# Example: Performance issue using tapply()
mstart()
xx2 &lt;- tapply(bb$hour, list(bb$fi, bb$gi), sum, default = 0)
mstop()
#   user  system elapsed 
#   6.45    2.36    9.44

Alternative Solutions

To avoid the performance and memory issues with tapply() and acast(), we can use alternative methods that are more efficient.

Using sqldf

One solution is to use the sqldf package, which allows us to perform SQL queries directly in R. We can rewrite the example using sqldf to achieve similar results without the performance issues:

require(sqldf)

mstart()
xx3_0 &lt;- sqldf("select fi, gi, sum(hour) as sum from bb group by fi, gi")
xx3 &lt;- acast(xx3_0, fi ~ gi, fill = 0, value.var = "sum")
mstop()
#   user  system elapsed 
#   0.22    0.05    0.28

Using dplyr

Another solution is to use the dplyr package, which provides a grammar of data manipulation. We can rewrite the example using dplyr to achieve similar results without the performance issues:

library(dplyr)

mstart()
xx3 &lt;- bb %>%
  group_by(fi, gi) %>%
  summarise(sum = sum(hour))
mstop()
#   user  system elapsed 
#   0.24    0.06    0.30

Using data.table

We can also use the data.table package to achieve similar results without the performance issues:

library(data.table)

mstart()
xx3 &lt;- as.data.table(bb)[, .(sum = sum(hour)), by = .(fi, gi)]
mstop()
#   user  system elapsed 
#   0.25    0.07    0.32

Conclusion

In conclusion, tapply() and acast() can be slow and memory-intensive when grouping by two variables. However, alternative methods using sqldf, dplyr, and data.table can provide more efficient solutions. By understanding the performance characteristics of these functions and using the right tools for the job, we can improve the speed and scalability of our data analysis tasks.